LSAT and Law School Admissions Forum

Get expert LSAT preparation and law school admissions advice from PowerScore Test Preparation.

User avatar
 Rebecca Salazar
  • Posts: 1
  • Joined: Apr 17, 2021
|
#86437
Hi!
I chose D rather than A.
My reasoning was that, because Melchior only spoke to the "cow's milk" (rather than "cow's milk formula") benefit in his argument, this was a distortion of the opposed reasoning. The rewording of the other premise by omitting "formula" constitutes a distortion. Therefore by saying this was an erroneous conclusion he thereby "attacked" the argument. And this was the reason M thinks was the wrong reasoning. What am I missing? Thank you!
User avatar
 Dave Killoran
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 4265
  • Joined: Mar 25, 2011
|
#86440
Hi Rebecca,

Thanks for the question! I'll respond with how LSAC would see this: they won't agree that this is a distortion. The first sentence references "formula made from cow's milk" and then the second references "cow's milk formula," and so it's clear that cow's milk is a primary component of this formula. To then continue on to discuss the benefits of cow's milk itself when it's clearly in the formula is not too much of a stretch in their eyes (or mine, for what it is worth). You can continue on to discuss components in this matter without committing flawed reasoning.

Let's consider the argument for a moment. First, it's a commonsense fact in LSAC's view that mother's nurse children with breast milk. So that's a "known" option as a basic fact of life. so here comes Melchior saying this cow's milk formula has been linked to diabetes. But regardless of that fact, it's okay to use it because it has some great nutrients. but shouldn't we consider the alternative and compare the two? Perhaps mother's milk has all the same nutrients and none of the drawbacks. And that's where Melchior's argument makes an error; it focuses on one option despite the drawbacks without looking elsewhere at all.

Please let me know if that helps. Thanks!

Get the most out of your LSAT Prep Plus subscription.

Analyze and track your performance with our Testing and Analytics Package.