- PowerScore Staff
- Posts: 8224
- Joined: Feb 02, 2011
Weaken. The correct answer choice is (B)
This question asks you to address a second hole in the stimulus argument, namely that we do not know the demographic makeup of these two communities. Sure, moving the library to Glenwood may put more people within walking distance, but that is of no consequence if the people in Glenwood do not read. If Redville happens to have a very highly educated populace that is more inclined to take advantage of a library in the area, then the overall argument will be weakened.
Answer Choice (A): Well, of course this is probably true. Since the current library is in Redville, it makes sense that more people who currently walk to the library live in Redville. This statement of basic common sense has no bearing on the stimulus argument.
Answer Choice (B): This is the correct answer choice. This answer choice punches through the above-described hole in the argument and demonstrates that, regardless of how many more people are within walking distance, the demographic makeup of the community will not necessarily lead to more library patrons.
Answer Choice (C): This answer choice clearly strengthens the argument and should be discarded quickly.
Answer Choice (D): This answer choice is irrelevant to the stimulus argument, because the stimulus author is concerned only with putting the library within walking distance of more people. He is not concerned with those individuals who drive or take public transportation.
Answer Choice (E): This answer choice would also strengthen the argument and should be discarded quickly.