- PowerScore Staff
- Posts: 7689
- Joined: Feb 02, 2011
Assumption. The correct answer choice is (E)
The conclusion of the argument asserts that Leibniz and Newton each independently discovered
calculus, and in drawing the conclusion the author addresses the possibility Newton may have
influenced Leibniz, and then rejects that possibility. A review of the argument does not reveal any
conspicuous flaws, and so upon encountering the question stem, you should expect to see a Defender
answer. As such, do not spend time trying to prephrase an answer—just make sure you know the facts
of the argument.
Answer choice (A): The argument is about the independent discovery of calculus; the author makes
no assumption that Leibniz did not tell anyone else, and indeed the fact that Newton did tell Leibniz
is accepted by the author as not undermining the conclusion.
Answer choice (B): Negate the answer: “A third person independently discovered calculus prior to
Newton and Leibniz.” Would this negated answer attack the argument? No, the author would just
assert that three different parties independently discovered calculus.
Answer choice (C): The author cites Newton’s letter as evidence that Newton felt he had disclosed
ideas to Leibniz prior to Leibniz’s publication date. No assumption is made that Newton felt that
what was disclosed allowed Leibniz to learn something important. If you are uncertain of this
answer, negate the choice to see if it weakens the argument.
Answer choice (D): This is clearly not an assumption of the argument because the author discusses
Newton’s letter to Leibniz prior to Leibniz’s publication date.
Answer choice (E): This is the correct answer. The answer can be difficult because it is somewhat
similar to answer choice (B), which many people already eliminated by the time they reached this
answer. Answer (E) is different from answer (B) because it involves learning details from a third
source. This is important because the conclusion references the independent discovery of calculus,
and so the author must believe that neither Newton nor Leibniz learned anything substantial about
calculus from other sources.
This elimination of an idea that weakens the argument is the essence of a Defender answer choice.
To further confirm the answer, consider the negation of this answer choice (“neither...nor” becomes
“either...or”): “Either Newton or Leibniz learned crucial details about calculus from some third
source.” This negated answer undermines the assertion that Leibniz and Newton each independently
discovered calculus. Consequently, this is the correct answer.