LSAT and Law School Admissions Forum

Get expert LSAT preparation and law school admissions advice from PowerScore Test Preparation.

 Administrator
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 8916
  • Joined: Feb 02, 2011
|
#25833
Complete Question Explanation

Resolve the Paradox. The correct answer choice is (C)

The apparent paradox in this stimulus is that although the level of unmetabolized sugar in the blood rises following the consumption of sugar, people who consume large amounts of sugar tend to have below-average levels of unmetabolized sugar in their blood. This situation is surprising, because you would have thought these sugar consumers would have above-average levels of sugar in their blood, whether or not you know the difference between sugar that has been metabolized and unmetabolized sugar. Since this is a surprising difference, your prephrase is that the correct answer will explain what makes these people, or the rate at which they metabolize sugar, different.

Answer choice (A): This choice is incorrect because it deals with a group that is not necessarily relevant to the apparent paradox. While you may generally associate the consumption of large amounts of sugar with obesity, nothing in this stimulus refers to the people being overweight.

Answer choice (B): This choice does nothing to clear up the paradox, because the source of the sugar is not at issue. This information would affect those who consume large amounts of sugar in the same way as those who do not. Remember that in a Paradox question, information that tells you a way in which two groups are the same will do nothing to explain the surprising difference between them.

Answer choice (C): This is the correct answer choice. This choice helps to resolve the paradox by explaining that when a person consumes large amounts of sugar their body changes, and begins to secrete abnormally high amounts of insulin, a sugar-metabolizing enzyme. This makes their bodies different from the norm in a way that causes the surprising difference in the stimulus to occur.

Answer choice (D): This choice does not help to resolve the paradox, because it does not explain what causes people who consume large amounts of sugar to have below-average levels of unmetabolized sugar in their blood. Even if they eventually fail to produce enough insulin, you would still be left with the mystery of why their unmetabolized sugar levels are so low.

Answer choice (E): While this choice explains why consuming sugar can increase the level of unmetabolized sugar in the blood, it does not help explain why people who consume large amounts of sugar have below-average levels of unmetabolized sugar in their blood.
 Etsevdos
  • Posts: 62
  • Joined: Oct 22, 2017
|
#41220
Without getting into the meaning of metabolizing sugar, how else could we answer the question? In haste, I missed meaning of c (metabolizing meaning it gets rid of the unmetabilized sugar)? Thx
 Eric Ockert
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 164
  • Joined: Sep 28, 2011
|
#41766
This question is designed in a way that you might anticipate where this answer is going. The paradox in the stimulus is that these individuals have large amounts of sugar but low amounts of unmetabolized sugar in their bloodstream. All sugar is either metabolized or unmetabolized as those two ideas are logical opposites of each other. So one easy way to resolve this situation is to just find a way that, even though there are low amounts of unmetabolized sugars, there are high amounts of metabolized sugars, which could explain the large amounts of sugar overall.

A parallel paradox might help. Suppose I told you that the states with large numbers of attorneys had below average numbers of uncertified attorneys. How could that be? Well it may be that these states just have large numbers of certified attorneys to counterbalance the low numbers of uncertified attorneys.

Answer choice (C) talks of lots of insulin " a sugar metabolizing enzyme. That could have increased the level of "metabolized" sugar while reducing the level of "unmetabolized" sugar, making it not all that surprising to see the situation in the stimulus (which is exactly the task on a Resolve the Paradox question).

Anyway, this might be one alternative way to view this without having to perfectly define "metabolize."

Hope that helps!

Get the most out of your LSAT Prep Plus subscription.

Analyze and track your performance with our Testing and Analytics Package.