- Thu Jan 21, 2021 12:18 am
I like that close reading! But, ultimately, the year that Laura J. Rosenthal's book was written in is irrelevant. Her approach results in projecting current ideological preoccupations inappropriately onto the past, no matter what year you are applying it in. The "current ideological preoccupations" does not refer to Rosenthal's approach--in other words, it is not Rosenthal's approach that is "current"; rather, "current ideological preoccupations" refers to the idea that, in the view of the author of passage A, the only difference between plagiarism, imitation, adaptation, repetition, and originality is that "those in power use the opprobrious term “plagiarism” when the work in question emanates from those whom they dislike." Any determination of plagiarism would be based on whether the people in power currently like the creator of the work or not.
So basically, if you and I today, in 2021, were trying to use Rosenthal's definitions for plagiarism vs. other similar things to determine if an older work was plagiarism or not, it would require that we impose our current 2021 morals onto a past work.
Hope this helps!