LSAT and Law School Admissions Forum

Get expert LSAT preparation and law school admissions advice from PowerScore Test Preparation.

 Administrator
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 8916
  • Joined: Feb 02, 2011
|
#65985
Complete Question Explanation

The correct answer choice is (A).

Answer choice (A): This is the correct answer choice.

Answer choice (B):

Answer choice (C):

Answer choice (D):

Answer choice (E):


This explanation is still in progress. Please post any questions below!
 ncolicci11
  • Posts: 43
  • Joined: Feb 09, 2020
|
#78052
Where is the support for answer A? I read through the paragraph and felt as if answer A eliminated the concerns the author had regarding TV reproduction and display. Does this refer to image size and definition?
 momgoingbacktoschool
  • Posts: 65
  • Joined: Aug 11, 2020
|
#79412
ncolicci11 wrote:Where is the support for answer A? I read through the paragraph and felt as if answer A eliminated the concerns the author had regarding TV reproduction and display. Does this refer to image size and definition?
Hi! You'll find support for answer A in the first two sentences of the third paragraph.
 g_lawyered
  • Posts: 211
  • Joined: Sep 14, 2020
|
#95247
Hi P.S.,
I have the same question @ncolicci11 has about answer A. I agree with @ncolicci11 that I saw extreme language in the first lines in paragraph 3 that wouldn't support the soft language in A "films can be artistically compromised to some extent." Where's the support for answer A?

Instead, I had answer choice contenders C & D. I picked D which states: "Even when they are distributed in uncompromised versions, films elicit variable responses from viewers, and thus they can rarely be expected to have the aesthetic impact that the filmmakers intend.". I thought this was supported in paragraph 4 last lines that states: "Second, when critics' comments are based on original, uncompromised versions of the films, they may raise false expectations with regard to the more or less faulty versions that are often available to viewers". This supports the negative viewpoint the author has on distributing films and the impact on the viewers. Why is D wrong?

It was hard for me to eliminate C, ultimately I eliminated it because I thought the extreme language didn't match the paragraph and paragraph doesn't mention the "technical limitations involved in the process of reproducing films". Is this what makes C incorrect?
Can someone please futher explain as RC is an area I'm struggling in?
Thanks in advance
User avatar
 katehos
PowerScore Staff
  • PowerScore Staff
  • Posts: 184
  • Joined: Mar 31, 2022
|
#95254
Hello!

The support for Answer Choice (A) comes from lines 22-25 of the passage. In these lines, the author is saying that television compromises films through the 'loss of image size and definition' as well as 'other ways.' If you continue reading, you'll see that those other ways include the types of alteration referenced in (A), such as commercial breaks and superimposed messages. While the film in (A) has not been altered to have commercials or messages, we know from lines 22-25 that the author believes simply showing a film on television comes with inherent compromises to image size and definition - so (A) is the correct answer!

Answer choice (B), however, is not supported by the passage. The passage doesn't really contain any information on if art critics consider films to be scholarly, so we can eliminate this answer.

Turning to answer choice (C), we notice right away that the verbiage in the answer choice is strong! (C) says that 'no reproduction of any one film,' so off the bat we know that, for this to be the correct answer, there will need to be strong textual support. Not only does the text not mention 'technical limitations,' but also, there's evidence that the author would disagree with this statement in the text. Lines 41-44 discuss how film is 'an exactly reproducible art form,' which makes it possible the author believes that it is possible to classify reproduced films as the original work. Therefore, we can eliminate (C).

At first glance, answer choice (D) can seem appealing. However, we don't really know what the author thinks of viewer's responses to uncompromised films. The passage centers largely around how external factors in reproduction - like subtitles and commercials - can compromise viewer's perception of films and thus creates a misalignment between critics and audiences. Looking to the text, there's no mention of how the subjective nature of films/their impact on audiences when uncompromised might hinder the 'aesthetic impact' of the film. Lines 50-54 do indicate a negative impact of critics viewing uncompromised films, but this is because when audiences view the compromised version, they might be expecting something else! So, we still don't know what impact audience's 'variable responses' to uncompromised films might have, and can thus eliminate (D).

Answer choice (E) can be eliminated for a similar lack of textual support. While the author mentions false expectations at the end of the passage, we just don't have enough information about the frequency of films not meeting standards set by writings to infer that 'most' films don't meet the standards.

I hope this helps answer both of your questions! :)
-Kate
 g_lawyered
  • Posts: 211
  • Joined: Sep 14, 2020
|
#95264
Hi Kate,
Thank you for your through explanation! I struggle with RC so I really need a thorough explanation as to why each answer is incorrect. I see that I misunderstood what Lines 50-54 were really saying and that why I fell for D.
Thanks again!

Get the most out of your LSAT Prep Plus subscription.

Analyze and track your performance with our Testing and Analytics Package.