- Fri Jun 29, 2018 1:10 pm
#47249
An unrepresentative sample, khodi, is one where the folks you surveyed or tested do not accurately reflect the type of people that you drew conclusions about. That could be because the sample is too small, or it could be because the people surveyed or tested differed in some important way from the people we drew conclusions about. Their answers aren't the issue - who they are, or how many of them there are, is what matters in a question about whether they are representative.
If we surveyed these same 100 50-year-olds and 50 20-year-olds and drew a conclusion that "as you age, you become more likely to donate blood", THEN we might have an unrepresentative sample problem because we only looked at two specific ages. Maybe 35-year-olds donate more than 50-year-olds? Maybe 75-year-olds donate less than 50-year-olds? The two snapshots of specific ages do not adequately represent the entire range of the aging spectrum.
Here, though, we surveyed the two specific groups, and we drew conclusions about only those two groups. Unless the groups were too small, or unless these particular people being surveyed were in some important way different from typical people of their ages, then an unrepresentative sample is unlikely to be the problem.
More to the point here, the author in this stimulus did NOT point to any potential problem with the sample. He had no problem with WHO we asked about blood donations. Rather, he was concerned about what ANSWERS we got. Pointing out that the answers may be inaccurate has nothing to do with whether the group we surveyed was representative of the group we drew conclusions about!
When looking at surveys, flaws are likely to be found in one of three categories: WHO we asked (was the sample representative?), WHAT we asked (were the questions unbiased and well constructed?) and what ANSWERS we got (did people give us accurate, truthful responses?) Don't mix those up!
Adam M. Tyson
PowerScore LSAT, GRE, ACT and SAT Instructor
Follow me on Twitter at
https://twitter.com/LSATadam