After all the past posts on this question, I'm still a bit confused. This question demands conditional diagramming and what has already been diagramed is a bit confusing. Specifically, there does not seem to be any evidence in the stimulus about "preventing" harm, only causing or not causing harm. There is nothing mentioning "preventing harm" in the stimulus and I think that is where my confusion lies since that term is the one that links the premises.
My diagram seems to make sense enabling easier linkage but I would like confirmation if it's actually accurate and if it is, am I reading the contrapositive correctly? I am using CAPS to show what and how I linked the premises.
It's not wrong to restrict liberty (fi not to do so, would) CAUSE HARM
Offend not CAUSE HARM
STEP 2: CONDITIONAL LINKAGE (using contrapositive of offend not cause harm)
It is not wrong to restrict liberties CAUSE HARM /offend
Reading the contrapositive of this statement is an exact match for the correct answer A. Did I arrive at the right conclusion using correct conditional logic linkage?
#12 - Politician: It is wrong for the government to restrict
This question actually only contains one conditional statment, in the first sentence:
Wrong to Restrict Liberty (WRL) Cause Harm (CH)
and its contrapositive:
Then it gives us specific examples that would fall under the general conditions given:
Publish = Liberty
Offend = Cause Harm
From this, we can see we have to apply the contrapositive to the situation, which gives us:
Meaning that it would be wrong to restrict publication of offensive material. Answer choice (A) reflects this, making it the correct answer.
Hope this helps!
I'm confused about this one because don't we need to negate "It is wrong" to "it is not wrong" in the first sentence...given the except rule?
You are correct. The first line of your quote shows " wrong to restrict liberty" as underlined when it should look crossed out. But the contrapositive below shows the correct relationship. not failing to restrict would allow for harm wrong to restrict liberty.
Hope that helps!
Wheres the answer????
The answer for this question is A, and you can find an explanation on page 1 of this thread: https://forum.powerscore.com/lsat/viewtopic.php?f=581&t=7485. Thanks!